Scores at a glance
| Source | Score | Sample |
|---|---|---|
| Metacritic — PC | 71 | 14 critic reviews |
| Metacritic — PS5 | 68 | 26 critic reviews |
| Metacritic — Xbox Series X|S | 78 | 8 critic reviews |
| OpenCritic | 72 top-critic average · 50% recommend | 53 critic reviews |
| Steam — English | 97% positive | 5,922 reviews (14,202 in all languages) |
The gap between critics and Steam players is the story here: critics scored it as a fun but thin sandbox, while players who bought it — often on sale and for co-op — rate it very highly.
What critics liked and disliked
Liked
- Physics-driven chaos and slapstick ragdolls.
- Deep goat customisation through gear.
- Four-player co-op on PC and current consoles.
- A much bigger open world than the 2014 game, with years of DLC since.
Disliked
- Shallow, repetitive side quests (PC Gamer’s Ted Litchfield singled out the side content).
- Technical bugs at launch (GamesRadar’s Alex Avard).
- Humour that repeats over a long session.
- Two-player cap on PS4, Xbox One, Switch and mobile.
IGN scored it 8/10, according to Wikipedia’s reception summary. I paraphrase rather than quote, because I only have the summaries, not the full reviews.
Who should buy it
- Co-op groups and couch players: strong yes, especially on PC, PS5 or Xbox Series where four can play.
- Fans of the 2014 game: yes — it is bigger and more polished, though the surprise is gone.
- Story or challenge seekers: probably not; the story is short (about 7½ hours) and missions are light.
- Bargain hunters: wait for sales — it was $8.99 on Steam and PlayStation on November 21, 2026 (see price check).
It is rated ESRB Teen and PEGI 12, so it is not aimed at young children despite the cartoon chaos.
Launch trailer: judge the humour for yourself. Video: Coffee Stain North on YouTube, uploaded 2022-11-17. The player loads only after you press play.
Better than the original?
Goat Simulator 3 is the direct follow-up to the 2014 game (there is no Goat Simulator 2 — see why it is called 3). It adds a far larger map, a structured story, co-op for four and ongoing DLC. Critics found it less surprising than the original because the joke is familiar, which is why its scores sit near the low 70s.
Questions people ask
Is Goat Simulator 3 good?
Is it better than the original?
Is Goat Simulator 3 good for kids?
How long is the story mode?
Sources
- Metacritic: Goat Simulator 3 — Metascores by platform (checked 2026-11-21)
- OpenCritic: Goat Simulator 3 — top critic average and recommend rate (checked 2026-11-21)
- Steam store page (app 850190) — price, sale price, system requirements, 74 achievements, languages, reviews (checked 2026-11-21)
- Wikipedia: Goat Simulator 3 — release history, reception summary, naming joke (checked 2026-11-21)
- HowLongToBeat: Goat Simulator 3 — community-submitted play times (checked 2026-11-21)
- Nintendo eShop: Switch — ESRB rating on the eShop listing (checked 2026-11-21)
- Goat Simulator Wiki (Fandom): Goat Simulator 3 — PEGI rating and platform list (checked 2026-11-21)